Gene Chapman has raised a very importent question. He asks what is the difference between Satyagraha and Dharna ? Are these activities not the same? I think it is essencial to understand the meaning of both these terms. Dharna verbally means 'Sitting' against some one under protest. It means you are not happy with someone's action and you are annoyed therefore you sit on Dharna to express your unhappiness and anger. The basic-uniqness of Satyagraha is that it is not against any body but for self-suffering for the ignorence of someone invidually or collectively. For example some Authority or indvidual responsible for the State. We can say Gandhiji's Satyagraha against South African Colonial regime or against Gen. Sumuts, who was head of the State.
'Satyagraha' is an act of self-suffering, It is for the wrong act or, acts of someone to make him realise that he/she has committ ed an inhuman act knowingly or unknowingly. It is an act of love through self-suffering.for someone who is angry and may be having hatered. Dharna is an act of hatered against some one who has commited anger and negetive feelings of unhappiness. There is no scope for love. It is power of love that satyagrahi expersses through his own suffrings. We can say it is an act of changing a person through the force of heart, and not not with body.force.
Satyagraha is an extraordinary act of human heart to express oneness with the one who does not want to be one with you due to his/her ignorence. In his book Hind Swaraj, Gandhiji had tried so show humanity that there is much more power in human mind than physical body. Human being can change the world with his positive mind power than what millions of violent army people could not do. We have several hundred examples of Army-Power-Violent force vs Power of love force. Actually it is the power of love only which bring qualitative change. That is what Gandhiji had shown through his extraordinary example.
Gandhiji had not done any thing like invention. He simply discover the hidden power of man. This power is within every one. The question is of bringing it out and putting it into social action. So we can say that Satyagraha is a Social Action which is the demand of the Time. Humanity has been fedup with the Body-Force-Show[ militarism], and now human being is also going disillusoned with materialism [ Blind Consumarism]. We have to move beyond militarism and materialism.
Comment
Comment by Gene Chapman on December 15, 2011 at 7:20pm Well, GeneChapman.blogspot.com carries a history of my work against the IRS (2nd plank of "The Communist Manifesto"), Jessie. The fasting brought attention in "The New York Time," for example, to the problem of Marxism within American government. The taxation of labor is one of the three primary attributes of slavery (personal income tax). This can only be accomplished by numbering people like cattle (Social Security Number) in order the extract the labor tax. I oppose all slavery.
Comment by Jessie carrel on December 15, 2011 at 7:01pm please explain to me your work MR. chapman i am confused on your purposes and fasting but i am intrigued at what you are trying to accomplish.
Comment by Gene Chapman on December 15, 2011 at 5:44pm So my 123 days of fasting against the IRS in 2003 thru 2004 was an appropriate satyagraha. I was fasting to awaken everyone to the evils of taxing labor, taxing property and numbering people like cattle (the three primary attributes of slavery in antiquity).
Comment by Balamurali Balaji on December 15, 2011 at 5:34pm GandhiTopia is a free service. You can support GandhiTopia by a donation or by buying our GandhiTopia products.


GandhiTopia and The Gandhi - King Community are Partners.
© 2013 Created by GandhiServe Foundation.
You need to be a member of GandhiTopia to add comments!
Join GandhiTopia